WTIC has recently pulled back ahead in performance of silver, but also has a substantial headstart in terms of time. All are still outpacing the Nasdaq's performance at this point in time.
Now for the Shiller data. The first of each pair are using his unaltered data. The second of each pair are using my interpolated Shadowstats CPI that I presented here about a month ago.
This one shows the most drastic difference between the two charts. Earnings reached all time lows in 2008/2009. It also shows the trend of the S&P increasing from 1921 onward, but a near break during the last recession. The price is nearly at the exact point where the 1929 bubble burst.
The shortest term indicators have rapidly reversed their decline.